Be a part of on daily basis info updates from CleanTechnica on piece of email. Or observe us on Google Info!

“Landman” is a television assortment broadcast on Paramount Plus, the digital subscription video on-demand and reside streaming service. I’ve watched lots of the totally different Taylor Sheridan assortment, somehow hoping {{that a}} romanticized Outdated West custom could also be blended with constructive representations of females. What I didn’t rely on from him was a working narrative in regards to the weak spot of renewable vitality and the current of Massive Oil for regularly residents. The gathering presents uneven, practically on a regular basis one-sided arguments in the direction of renewable vitality and the work of native climate activists.

Core social media narratives like these on Paramount Plus are shaping discourse throughout the native climate catastrophe due to the persistent “stickiness” of mis- and dis-information — and they also’re influencing people to disregard the hazard of fossil fuels. Sheridan’s characters boast how the Texans spherical them may in no way protect their life with out ample portions of oil and gasoline. Proof quite the opposite elements to a powerful potential for renewables to substitute for fossil gasoline vitality, thanks.

It’s not merely all through the US media superior that native climate misinformation confuses regularly of us. Renewables like rooftop picture voltaic, gridscale wind and picture voltaic, and superior storage now current spherical 40% of {the electrical} vitality in Australia’s vital grid. The catch? Fewer than 1 in 10 Australians know it, according to a survey by the Native climate Council.

Listed below are some examples of the “Landman” vitality mis-/disinformation. Sammy Roth of the LA Cases calls such examples half of a much bigger “propaganda that serves to lionize the oil enterprise.”

Lithium is Worse by Implication than Fossil Fuels

“Properly, I can promise you all these Chinese language language lithium mines are unhealthy for the setting.”

The race in the direction of net-zero emissions depends upon intently on lithium to vitality electrical autos along with to retailer wind and photo voltaic vitality. Positive, new battery experience should be developed using additional widespread, environmentally-friendly provides. The sourcing, establishing, and disposal of lithium-ion batteries does have present chain air air pollution, certain, but it surely certainly does not lastly look at to what we’re at current doing with fossil fuels.

A far more nuanced technique that Sheridan may need chosen would have been to declare that, to fulfill sustainability goals, we now have to strike a steadiness between vitality sourcing and renewable developments. Take into account it this style: whenever you burn gasoline, it’s gone. Within the meantime, it’s possible you’ll recharge a battery various cases.

(Observe the Othering inside the “Landman” quote that cites China’s contribution to lithium mining.) 

Cows are So Cute — So What if They Burp?

“They’re saying {{that a}} cattle burp is unhealthy for the setting. Now they should get rid of all the cattle.”

Cattle burps generate vital portions of methane, a greenhouse gasoline (GHG) that is 25 cases stronger than carbon dioxide in warming the planet. In precise truth, animal agriculture produces additional GHG emissions than all the world’s cars and vans blended. Methane has a rather a lot elevated world warming potential (GWP) than carbon dioxide.

Capturing enteric methane emissions from cows working unfastened inside the fields is an issue of epic proportions. Positive, the custom of meals ought to basically proceed to morph with the cases — about three-quarters of all world agricultural land is vulnerable to substantial native climate disruptions. Like many hog farmers, cattle ranchers may uncover themselves struggling to help their herds, whether or not or not it is from dangerous storms or clients’ shifting preferences to plant-based diets.

Do Photograph voltaic Panels Really Kill Birds and Whales?

“They put picture voltaic panels and wind turbines on these lands that kill these birds, disrupt their patterns. Then they stick ‘em inside the ocean and kill the whales.”

Chook species and whales are beneath menace from native climate change. Fossil gasoline and nuclear vitality crops actually set off additional fowl deaths than picture voltaic or wind vitality. Moreover they threaten the very ecosystems fowl species rely on. Furthermore, fowl deaths from wind turbines have dropped considerably (per kWh) as a result of the experience has matured, and annual fowl lack of life totals from cats, dwelling home windows, and autos each dwarf annual fowl lack of life totals from wind vitality.

North Atlantic correct whales are extraordinarily endangered, and their survival is at extreme menace due to a combination of vessel strikes and entanglements in fishing gear. And, reverse to a extraordinarily publicized article filled with disinformation, NOAA Fisheries does not anticipate and has not permitted — or proposed to authorize — mortality or extreme injury of whales for any wind-related movement.

Are Wind and Photograph voltaic Additional Pricey than Pure Gasoline?

Wind vitality “is twice as pricey as pure gasoline, and picture voltaic 4 cases as pricey.”

A LCOE analysis from Lazard says it clearly — renewable vitality from wind and picture voltaic sources is cheaper than electrical vitality from thermal generators powered by coal, oil, or methane gasoline. Interval. And that’s with out counting the carbon worth of their rivals and the affect of President Joe Biden’s Inflation Low cost Act, which has added tens of billions of latest financial incentives to the mixture.

Photograph voltaic and wind vitality have comparatively low functionality parts, and making them truly useful and similar to a fossil gasoline vitality plant in utility means together with stationary vitality storage as properly. Together with in storage, onshore wind vitality has the an identical low worth as blended cycle gasoline vitality crops, and utility-scale picture voltaic should not be far off.

Photograph voltaic is Solely Good for 8/24 Hours inside the Day — Really?

“On its most interesting day of the 12 months, a photo voltaic vitality plant generates electrical vitality for about 8 hours.”

Misinformation about picture voltaic is rampant. The price of together with batteries to wind and picture voltaic crops positioned in areas that face transmission congestion is forgotten on this “Landman” assertion. Native climate scientist Mark Jacobson deconstructed a present analysis for us at CleanTechnica that talked about this degree.

“This paper reveals that the precept grid on this planet’s fifth largest monetary system was able to current better than 100% of {the electrical} vitality that it used from solely 4 clear renewable sources – –picture voltaic, wind, hydroelectric, and geothermal — for anyplace from 5 minutes to over 10 hours per day for 98 out of 116 days all through late winter, all of spring, and early summer season, along with for 132 days all through your full 12 months of 2024, with out its grid failing. The growth of picture voltaic, wind, and battery storage, notably, resulted in fossil gasoline use dropping 40% in the middle of the 116 day interval and 25% all through your full 12 months of 2024 relative to 2023.”

Nevertheless the disinformation continues nonetheless. Michigan native climate advocates have wanted to refute a breathless viral meme knowledgeable the story of devious deep-state plotters who’ve been conniving with greedy globalist picture voltaic builders to cut down a pristine tract of virgin outdated improvement forest — nope, false, a lie.

Is Wind Power Clear, or Isn’t It?

“There’s nothing clear about this” wind vitality. 

A “Landman” character outlines how a whole lotta fossil gasoline is used to manufacture, transport, and assemble each turbine, so that, “in its 20-year lifespan, it gained’t offset the carbon footprint of establishing it.” What he’s not saying is that wind is an vitality provide that could be a viable and clear totally different to fossil fuels, and the worldwide put in functionality of wind vitality has many monetary and environmental advantages.

Wind turbines do not produce any air pollution or emissions all through operation which may harm the setting, in addition to these required for maintenance (which are minimal). The primary drawbacks of wind vitality are extreme upfront costs, variability in wind speeds, and unsuitability in areas that do not have mounted winds. Wind moreover reduces power-sector emissions of carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and sulfur dioxide. These reductions, in flip, current public properly being and native climate benefits which could be greater than wind’s grid-system value. Massive Oil has additional upfront air air pollution and 0 environmental benefits when it’s burned.

In its place of doing a deep dig, Sheridan lies inside the voice of a “Landman” character, “Getting oil out of the underside’s basically essentially the most dangerous job on this planet. We don’t do it ‘set off we want it. We do it ‘set off we run out of decisions.”

Can’t Electrify Each factor on account of We don’t have the Transmission Strains

“If your complete world decided to go electrical tomorrow, we don’t have the transmission strains to get {the electrical} vitality to the cities… It may take 30 years if we started tomorrow.”

There’s a kernel of truth to this place. Nonetheless, a visionary filmmaker may need described the value of together with batteries to wind and picture voltaic crops positioned in areas that face transmission congestion. Optimistic, optimum configurations of hybrid VRE+battery crops might fluctuate between areas kinds and between picture voltaic and wind, however the crops can contribute to every vitality and functionality markets.

It’s essential to refine long term planning processes and provide notion into future circumstances as renewable vitality and battery deployment expands over time.

Remaining Concepts about Landman: The Power behind Paramount Media

Paramount World—the sprawling media empire behind CBS, MTV, and one amongst Hollywood’s most storied movie studios— was acquired by Skydance Media in late 2024. The superior deal, worth over $8 billion, occurred in a two-step transaction that involved Skydance first shopping for Paramount’s controlling agency, Shari Redstone’s Nationwide Amusements, after which merging Skydance and Paramount. Based mostly by David Ellison in 2006, Skydance specializes in motion pictures, animation, television, video video video games, and sports activities actions.

The week after the November election, once-and-future President Donald J. Trump gathered his prime advisers inside the tea room at his Florida resort, Mar-a-Lago, to plan the transition to his second-term authorities, as reported by the New York Cases. Two valued houseguests have been the billionaire Tesla CEO Elon Musk and the billionaire co-founder of Oracle, Larry Ellison.

“I launched the two richest people on this planet proper this second,” Trump knowledgeable his advisers, according to a person who was inside the room. “What did you ship?”

Ellison brings an unlimited communications conglomerate to Trump’s ft. Is he, identical to the “Landman” billionaire, any person who has helped to elect nice politicians and to supply lobbying to maintain up billions of {{dollars}} in subsidies to Massive Oil? It’s onerous to make clear in some other case.

Mr. Ellison, please rein in your boy Taylor and use your ample billions for clear vitality, the widespread good, and truth.